Best Mallet Putter

Straight Back – Straight Thru: The Best Mallet Putters

Are you looking for the best mallet putters to take your putting to the next level?

If so, we did some research and found the best ones for your game. At the Left Rough, we know how important it is to choose the right putter.

The right putter in your hands can help you build confidence, shoot lower scores, and elevate all areas of your game. On the other hand, if your putter makes you cringe and you worry about 3-putting more than draining putts, your game is probably suffering. 

One way to change your total number of putts per round is making sure that you’re using the right style of putter. Because if you’re using the wrong one, you’re making golf much harder on yourself.

In this post, we’ll break down how a mallet can help your game, what to think about when buying, and our seven picks for mallet putters.

5 Factors for Picking The Best Mallet Putter

When it comes to picking your new putter, it’s not a decision that should be made lightly. 

Why?

Because the putter is (by far) the most important club in the bag. Unless you chip in or make an ace, you’re going to use it on every single hole, every single round. In fact, it probably makes up 30% or more of every single shot you hit! 

The point being, your putter needs to be your best friend on the links. It should be there to help you go low when you’re striking it well and salvage you round when you can’t seem to find the center of the club. 

Before just choosing one on a whim, make sure that you research this decision and find the best one for your game. Here are some of the biggest factors to think about when choosing your brand-new putter.

Mallet Putter vs. High MOI Putter

First off, do you want a mallet putter or a high MOI putter?

While they are more similar to a high MOI putter than a blade, mallets are still unique. Even though they’ve lost some popularity in recent years, a lot of golfers still prefer this size and shape when standing over the ball.

If you’re already using a mallet and looking for an upgrade, then you should be fine. But if you’re playing a high MOI putter now (like a Taylormade Spider), understand the difference between the two putters. 

First, it’ll be a bit smaller than an MOI putter so be prepared for the visual differences. Second, it will usually feel different in your hands as it weighs differently as well. If you’re not concerned and ready to buy your next mallet putter, here are some things to consider. 

Shape and Weight of Putter Head 

The first thing golfers should think about is the putter head itself. If you’re coming from a blade putter, the club head will feel a lot bigger. But if you’re coming from a high MOI putter, the club head might be nearly the same size or even slightly smaller.

Nowadays mallets have evolved and there are tons of different styles available. Some might be the traditional “half moon” style while others have sharper edges or holes in the club head as well. 

Plus, the perimeter weighting works best for golfers who need some forgiveness on long putts. The weight for a lot of these clubs can also be adjusted with additional weight kits as well.

Regardless of which putter you’re coming from, you want a putter shape that looks good to you. Remember, confidence plays a huge role in putting so you want to look down at a club that makes you feel like Tiger Woods in 2000 (well maybe not quite that confident, but you get the point). 

Forgiveness

Once you find a putter that looks good, another important factor when choosing your new putter is making sure it has plenty of forgiveness. Luckily, mallets putters have a higher MOI (moment of inertia) than a blade putter so you should have plenty of forgiveness. Not to mention, the club head usually has perimeter weighting to help golfers on poorly struck putts.  

These are the perfect putters for beginners and can be a great putter for high handicappers as well.

Shaft Type

The third thing to consider is the shaft type. Each one has a different amount of offset and impacts how the club looks while you’re standing over the ball.

The three main types are:

Plumbers Neck 

The first type of putter shaft is known as the plumbers neck. If you’re a golfer who sometimes takes it straight back and straight through but other times have some arc, this is a good fit. This type of hosel typically has some toe hang so you can square up the putter at impact. 

Double Bend Shaft 

If you prefer to take it straight back and straight through, a double bend is a phenomenal choice. The way this shaft is configured there is minimal face rotation throughout the putting stroke. This should help you hit straighter putts directly at your intended target without pushing or pulling. 

Best Mallet Putter

Center Shaft 

The final type is a center shaft. Unlike the two previous, the shaft goes directly into the middle of the clubhead. For some golfers, this might look very strange if you’ve used a heel shafted putter for a long time. 

But these shafts can really help you groove a consistent, straight back, straight through swing. Since they pair with face balanced putters, this isn’t a good fit if you have a lot of arc in your stroke as it’s extremely difficult to square up the putter face at impact. 

Alignment Aid

Once you pick the right shaft, make sure that you choose a putter that has enough alignment aids for your game. One of the biggest mistakes so many golfers make it not setting up at their target. While they may get the read right, their alignment is off and it’s easy to miss a ton of putts.

Luckily, club manufacturers have realized this common error and created putters with increased alignment. As you’ll see with the putters on this list, most clubs have one or several types of alignment lines to help you set up square. 

Plus, since mallets are larger than blades, it’s much easier to line up properly as there is more space to create lines or arrows. Mallets will help you line it up much straighter! 

Length of Putter 

While all the previous factors are important, you can’t forget about the putter length as well. Regardless of which putter (or putter type) you choose, it’s extremely important that it’s the right length.

Most putters range from 33 to 35 inches with some going as short as 32 inches and as long as 36 inches. Click here to learn more about putter length and how it impacts your performance on the greens. 

The 7 Best Mallet Putters on the Market

Now that you know what to look for with your new putter, let’s get into the best choices:

1. Odyssey Triple Track Mallet Putters

One of the best brands in the putter industry is Odyssey Golf. Not only are they highly respected in the industry and create high-quality golf clubs, they also were one of the earliest companies to offer a mallet putter. Plus, they revolutionized the putting world with their 2-ball mallet putters which is still one of the most popular styles on the market today.

Odyssey has unveiled their newest line – the Triple Track. This series is all about helping golfers get lined up square to their target. Each of the seven different putting options come with a red and blue alignment system to help you set up square. 

Visually, it’s very easy to line your golf ball up to the center of the face and ensure you aren’t aimed right or left. Plus, there is a huge selection and more than one style for your game. 

Pros

  • Incredible alignment. These putters are so easy to line up and you will never have to worry about setting up square again.
  • Moderately priced. Despite tons of new technology, these putters are priced very well in the market.
  • Improved weighting will help your tempo on every single putt. This should help you accelerate through the ball and improve your distance control. 
  • Soft feel with the micro hinge star face insert. This newly designed face insert will give you better feel on the greens from any length distance. 

Cons

  • No adjustable weights.
  • Not as many custom shaft options as some manufacturers.

If you’re looking for a mallet style, we suggest the Seven, 2-ball or traditional look of the Marxman. All three models come with the triple tracker alignment.

>>Click here to learn more and find the lowest prices for Triple Track mallet putters.

2. TaylorMade Spider FCG Mallet Putters

TaylorMade has become a big name in the putter world since they made a splash with their Spider series. Now, they offer more options than almost any other brand giving you plenty to choose from. One of the newest picks is the Spider FCG series.

This brand-new product line is only available in mallet putters which is quite rare in the golf world. That being said, they didn’t hold back any punches and deliver another high-quality putter that is great for golfers who love mallets! 

This new putter blends together all of their technology into one epic club. As TaylorMade said on their website, “Looks like a mallet, feels like a blade and forgives like a spider.” 

Pros

  • Adjustable weight kit.
  • Awesome tricolor design (black, white, and gold).
  • T-Sightline True Path makes aiming easier than ever. 
  • High MOI mallet putter that works great with an arc stroke. 
  • Enhanced CG (two thirds of the weight is in the front part of the head).
  • Three hosel options available (L neck, single bend, and heel shaft).

Cons

  • Not the best mallet putter for a straight back, straight through putting style. 

If you’re a blade player or someone looking to switch from the Spider to this type of putter, this could be the easiest transition without screwing up your game. 

>>Click here to find the lowest price for the Spider FCG putter. 

3. Cleveland Golf Huntington Beach Soft Premier Mallet Putter

If you read our list of best blade putters, you know that we think highly of the Huntington Beach series. While the blade is great, don’t sleep on the mallet ones either. 

Cleveland’s product line just got an amazing update to make them even better than before. Plus, these are incredible putters that any golfer can afford.

Pros

  • Incredibly affordable. 
  • Center shaft options available. 
  • Super clean”gray satin” putter head and shaft design.
  • Precision milled face and unique diamond pattern (similar to the PXG). 
  • Speed optimized faced technology for amazing speed control even on poorly hit putts.

Cons

  • Best for straight back, straight through players. 
  • All black design alignment lines might make aiming harder for some golfers. 

If you prefer a traditional mallet style check out the Huntington Beach Soft Premier 14 putter. Or, check out some of the other options like the Premier 11S or the 10.5C. 

>>Click here to find the lowest prices on these brand new putters. 

4. TaylorMade TP Patina Collection

While TaylorMade is most known for their Spider putter line, they also offer a huge selection of blades and mallets as well. One of our favorite choices is the TP Patina Collection which made the Golf Digest Gold List. They offer seven different putters within this product line and five of them are mallet styles.

Pros

  • Several different shaft options available.
  • Pure roll face insert has incredible feel and a great sound at impact. 
  • Adjustable weight system using two screws and up to 20g weight. 
  • Amazing alignment with their “Double Sightline” and dots for even better aim. 
  • Face balanced putter design making it ideal for straight back, straight through style.  

Cons

  • Only one color option available. 
  • Not as sleek of a design as some of the others on this list.

For the most traditional half circle style, we suggest going with the TP Patina Collection Ardmore 1 putter. 

>>Click here to find the lowest price on the best mallet putter from TaylorMade. 

5. Odyssey Stroke Lab Mallet Putter

While the Triple Track is all about alignment, Odyssey has several other putter lines that help with more than just that. Let’s introduce the Odyssey Stroke Lab (and Stroke Lab black) putters.

These clubs are some of the most highly reviewed ones on the market and come in ten different shapes (including four non blades). Here’s how Odyssey described this unique product line, “Our new Stroke Lab putters actually help improve the golfer’s stroke, including backswing length, face angle at impact, head speed through impact and tempo, all through a profound change in weight distribution made possible by an innovative new shaft.”

If you’re not worried about alignment but looking to improve your stroke and tempo, one of these could be the mallet putter for you.

Pros

  • Clean design in silver or black.
  • Six different styles to fit your eye. 
  • Several hosels available to match your putting stroke. 
  • Unique shaft design making it 40 grams lighter than a traditional steel shaft.
  • Alignment aids are prominent on every model and make it easy to set up square. 

Cons

  • Not as much alignment aid as Triple Track products. 

>>Click here to check out the Stroke Lab options. 

6. Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom Mallet Putter

Another top brand in the putting world is Scotty Cameron although they are more known for their blades than mallet design. But with the Phantom X series, Scotty Cameron has shown they are 100% focused on creating some of the best mallet putters. 

The Phantom X5, X6, X7, X8 and 12 are some of the best mallet putters on the market. They are designed to make alignment easy with their yellow dots and wider top lines.

Pros

  • Adjustable weights.
  • Five style options available. 
  • Multiple shaft options in every putter.  
  • Sleek silver, black, and neon yellow design. 
  • Solid putter face technology made of 6061 aluminum. 

Cons

  • More expensive than most on this list.
  • Not every golfer will love the yellow alignment aids.

>>Click here to buy the newest Scotty Cameron mallet putter now. 

7. Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Mallet Putter 

If your number one concern is budget, then look no further than the Pinemeadow PGX mallet putter. This is one of the most affordable putters on the market.

Pinemeadow Golf Men's PGX Putter (Right Hand)

Pros

  • Soft feel.
  • PGX headcover is included. 
  • Available as a 2-ball model as well.
  • Clean white, black, and neon green design.
  • 380g making it “tour weighted” and great for fast greens. 

Cons

  • No face insert.
  • Only available in 34 inches.
  • No shaft or grip customizations.  

This is the best mallet putter for golfers on a budget or beginners who want to test out a mallet style without breaking the bank.

>>Click here to find out more about the Pinemeadow mallet putter. 

FAQs

Do you have more questions about the best mallet putters? If so, we got answers! 

Are mallet putters better?

Yes and no.

Depending on your skill level and putting stroke, a mallet putter might be better than a blade putter. The key word here being “might.” If you have an arc stroke, you should probably stick with a blade style.

But if you have a more straight back, straight through path (or want to create one), then I would suggest that you go with a mallet putter for the most success.

Should I switch to a mallet putter?

If you’re like most golfers, switching putters is a big decision. This usually doesn’t happen on a whim. Instead, making a putter switch usually happens when you’re in a slump and need something new to jumpstart your game. 

As you probably know, there isn’t much worse than hitting the golf ball well but scoring poorly! So if you need a spark to your game, switching putters might be just what you need.

But switching to a mallet depends on the type of putter you’re currently playing with. For example, if you’ve been playing with a blade putter for years, switching to a mallet could take some getting used to. 

First off, the shape of the head is different and will look huge compared to your standard blade. Second, the weight is much different and might take some practice on the putting green before taking it right on the course. You might need to alter the adjustable weights if there are any as well to get enough toe hang. 

On the other hand, if you’re putting with a high MOI putter now (like a TaylorMade spider), this might be an easier transition to a mallet. Since you’re familiar with a larger putterhead, this should help when you make the switch. 

Are mallet putters more forgiving? 

Compared to blade putters, yes, mallet putters offer golfers a lot more forgiveness. Each putter from the list above has a much larger sweet spot than most blades and should help with your off center hits. 

Since the club is more forgiving your poorly hit putts should end up closer to the hole resulting in fewer putts throughout the round. While they are forgiving, they’re ultimately not as forgiving as a high MOI putter. 

Why do pros use blade putters?

If you’re tuning into the PGA Tour on TV, you’re likely to see more players using blades than at your local golf club. The reason that Tour players and scratch golfers use blade putters is the same reason they use blade irons – they find the sweet spot consistently.

Since these guys are incredibly consistent compared to the average golfer, they don’t need to worry about mishits on the club head as much. Plus, blade putters have more “feel” than a mallet or high MOI putter which some players enjoy. Not to mention, some want blades as the toe hang works well with an arc stroke.

While blades used to be common on the PGA Tour, they aren’t as much as before. Now, top golfers like Jason Day, Rory McIlroy and many golfers others are opting for a high MOI style instead of blades. 

Remember, always play the club that works best for your game! 

Wrapping Up

Hopefully, you now have a better understanding of the best mallet putter choices on the market. While mallets aren’t as common as blades, they might be just the switch that your game needs. With additional weighting and forgiveness, they could really help your game and improve your distance control. 

Remember, if you tend to take the putter straight back and straight through, a mallet putter is likely a good fit for your game. Plus, there are even options out there like the TaylorMade FCG which looks like a mallet but is great for a blade stroke.  

Finally, don’t forget to get the correct length and shaft bend to give yourself the best opportunity to drain more putts. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Alert: Content is protected !!